Skip to main content

How Good Is Modi As A Reformer - An Analysis Of Modi's India

Modi As A Reformer

Before Prime Minister Modi's US visit and the first ever Modi-Trump meeting, several global media houses have analyzed the three years of Modi's government. They are doing their best to highlight the failure of the Modi government, downplaying all the achievements of India during three years. Of all those, the Economist magazine's analysis, I think, is the one that deserves good attention.

According to the Economist, prime minister Narendra Modi is not much as a big reformer as he seems. In the beginning, the article gives some credit to Modi for boosting the economic growth of India. It says, before the arrival of Modi, India was growing at a relatively slower rate of 6.4% than after the 2014 election. In 2015, India became the world's fastest growing economy with a growth rate of 7.9%. It also mentioned the economic reforms like GST and Bankruptcy law which have been successfully passed by the legislature.

But, then, it says "These facts are deceiving. The GST, although, was much needed to end the confusing array of taxes, the present government has unnecessarily complicated it by making it too bureaucratic in nature, which has greatly reduced its efficiency."

The article also blamed state-owned banks, immersed in debt, for delaying the financial reform. To curb the problem of declining loans and rising NPA, it suggests the government the option of privatization. it says, “the lending to the industry is contracting for the first time in 20 years; Mr Modi should recapitalize state-owned banks and sell them off.”

And, according to The Economist, demonetisation was counterproductive. It has only hamstrung legitimate business without doing much to the illegitimate ones and taken the growth rate of the Indian economy back to 6.1%, even worse than when Mr Modi came to power.

The article tries to project Modi as a right-wing Hindu zealot citing reasons like the appointment of a controversial man as chief minister of the most populous state of India, Uttar Pradesh. It tried to project the rise of Hindu nationalism in India with Yogi Adityanath becoming chief minister of UP who immediately pursued a full crackdown on illegal slaughtering houses after coming to power.

My assessment:

In a huge democracy like India, having remarkable pluralism, bringing a reform of any kind – political, economic or social – is an extremely cumbersome task. Sometimes, it becomes just impossible. For example, whenever the government will to bring a Uniform Civil Code(UCC), mentioned in the Directive Principles of State Policy, to further the equality principle, the Muslim community becomes agitated for no good reason. And, in the name of secularism, there is also widespread protest in different parts of the country against the UCC. The Muslims make it a religious issue, making the progress of UCC heading to nowhere.

It is only easy to bring reform in a dictatorial regime or by the means of violent revolution. In democracies, it will take its time as the leaders have to take care of the public sentiments. However, there is a scenario in which a democracy can be reformed. It is when both the ruling party government and opposition think and only think of the welfare of the people. This concept stems from idealism, practically it is very difficult, especially in India where being in opposition means opposing every movement of the government.

Mr Modi has brought down monetary governmental corruption to nil. This is quite a big achievement of Modi's government, especially if you remember the situation in India before the 2014 election. Certainly, the corruption has not been fully eradicated, but the government is hoping to achieve that too.

Yes, the state-owned banks is a burden on the economy. Banking is just like any other business and this business need not be carried out by the state; it just needs to be regulated. Banks were nationalized for building the trust of the people in banks. At that time, India was an economically unliberal country struggling with socialist ideology. The absence of competition among the public sector banks and a lack of professionalism can be easily noticed. Privatization of the banks is a very good option, it should be done as early as possible.

Nonetheless, I agree with most of the points of the article and consider it as a legitimate one, I have a serious disagreement with these:



Conclusion:


Like any other western media analysis, the Economist article also seems to be biased. Others just blatantly try to ridicule India, in which they end up ridiculing themselves. The Economist, on the other hand, tried to do it by cleverly selling some intellectual facts. It has ignored all the achievements of Modi's India despite naming the cover of the magazine in capital letters as "MODI'S INDIA".

Still, I would say is really good, considering its opinion on various issues of India and giving attention to the real issues; it is of excellent quality if we compare it with other foreign media that cover India or, in particular, has covered the three years of Modi's India.

So, I think, it doesn't matter whether this article criticizes or praises Modi, the only thing I liked here is that it talked about India of the 21st century unlike other so-called global news brands still having the picture of India as a land of snake-charmers and superstitious believers, even when India is the only country that has successfully accomplished its Mars mission in its maiden attempt and launching hundreds of foreign satellites on a regular basis. They just can't digest the fact that India has moved on and is progressing at a rapid rate.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Sanjay Dutt Hero Or Villain? A Review Of Sanju Baba’s Journey As Both

The Sanjay Dutt biopic “Sanju” was released on 29th of June made by one of the best filmmakers of the B-town, Rajkumar Hirani. It was marketed as an “unbelievably true story”. Indeed Dutt’s journey is unbelievable. However, there have been many unbelievable personalities too such as Dawood or Osama. Sorry for comparing Dutt with Don and Terrorist. The drugs, booze, women, and AK 56 make Sanju a largely negative character in the real world. Not his fault, according to the film. Some people say Sanjay Dutt doesn’t deserve a biopic as there are many “good” people, with their “good” work, that go unnoticed. The argument over whether Dutt deserves a biopic or not is inane. It’s like saying Dhoni’s biopic should have been made after his retirement. The truth is, biopics are made on interesting people, not the good ones, especially if it is of commercial in nature. If that interesting people is a negative character, it gets more publicity. Also, a “fictional” biopic cannot be real. Be i...

The Marvels Of Board Exams

AFTER AN EXHILARATING HOLI, comes the boring and haunting board exam, the exam for which no amount of preparation gives an impression of sufficiency. Students across the nation get excited as well as depressed. They are ‘excitingly depressed’. Excited to give the final exam of their school life, to enter into a new world, and depressed thinking what society would say if their marks won't be that good. Sharma Ji’s meritorious child is making things worse. While the level of questions asked in the exams has become easy these days, the quality of students being produced is decreasing, WhatsApp, Social Media and expansion of internet are to blame. The internet and smartphones may help students in their higher studies, but it misfires in case of younger kids. It only serves as a distraction, the biggest of modern times. Earlier, when kids go out to play some sports , it was treated as a distraction from studies. But now, it has been understood clearly that it wasn't seeing...

A Mesmerizing Winter Morning

WAKING UP on a winter morning takes courage. It is a sort of sacrifice only a few people are able to make, those having a remarkable will-power. Unless you have a strong reason to get something done, making this sacrifice is a herculean task, almost impossible. In winter, there is a joy in oversleeping, in cuddling up under a nice warm and cosy blanket. What most people do is— they wake up, see the time, and get back to sleep again. Even when being awake, it becomes extremely difficult to actually get up and resume our work or study. What happens is that our mind succumbs to the bodily comfort of enjoying a great peaceful sleep underneath a blanket. I, too, belong to this group, the group that is not ready to give up morning sleep easily on any day; and when it comes to giving up the sleep of a winter morning, we just cannot. However, one day, on a fairly cold winter morning, when I supposed to be in the sleep mode, I not only got up early but went for a walk too. Dressed up ...

Indian Rupee Demonetisation: Why It Cannot End Corruption Or Even Black Money

It was November 8, when Prime Minister Narendra Modi, in a dramatic announcement, decided to scrap or demonetise two high-value Indian currency of the denomination of ₹500 and ₹1000. It means 85% of currency in circulation will no longer be a legal tender. All that precious notes have been converted into wastepaper overnight. It became the biggest talking point in every Indian household  —  from Kashmir to Kanyakumari and from Kutch to Arunachal Pradesh. After all, in a country where 98% of all transactions are conducted in cash, it was a big jolt. Demonetisation is usually associated with degrading economies and hyperinflation and often done by military dictatorships. It was surprising that a popular and democratically elected prime minister of a booming economy has resorted to demonetisation. Black money is the money held by people that have evaded taxation. It is illegal hoarding of unaccounted money which tends to exacerbate inequality because the biggest evas...

A Glimpse Into The Life Of India's Most Trusted Batsman - Rahul Dravid and The World Cup

image credits-  Chubby Chandru THE LEGENDARY CRICKETER, Rahul Dravid has finally quenched his desire of lifting a Cricket World Cup, though not as a skipper, not even as a player — but as a coach. Undoubtedly, it is the hard work of the boys involved in the game, who give their output on the ground and are directly responsible for the results. However, the hard work needs to be in the right direction and like any other sport, in cricket too, the team needs a right strategy to win the game. That's when the role of experience comes in, and who is better experienced than “the wall” himself. At his time, he was the most-trusted batsman of the Indian team. He performed when everyone else in the team surrender. He is the one who absorbed the deadly bowling attacks with remarkable ease. He is the one who rescued the team from the jaws of a humiliating defeat. He is the one who set up a massive target for the opponents and by the mere presence of the wall shatters their hopes. ...

Does India As A State Obliged Towards Her Citizens For Providing Them Employment?

As the Modi-led BJP government has failed to rescue India from Job crisis in its five-year term, the question is whether the government has done enough to maintain the equilibrium in the job market of the country? And whether or not the government should be held liable for creating this crisis in the first place? Screenshot from movie 3 idiots Article 41 {Right to work, to education and to public assistance in certain cases} under DPSP says: “The State shall, within the limits of its economic capacity and development, make effective provision for securing the right to work, to education and to public assistance in cases of unemployment, old age, sickness and disablement, and in other cases of undeserved want.” The DPSP cannot be enforced by any court, but the principles laid down in this part are nevertheless fundamental in the governance of the country, and it should be the duty of the State to apply these principles in making laws. We also need to look back to Mo...

Why Unemployment Should Be The Blazing Problem For 2019 Election

In 2014, BJP in their campaign claimed that: there is no Modi-wave but it is the Tsunami of Narendra Modi (TsuNaMo). It now appears that the TsuNaMo was actually Tsunami of joblessness and has silently brought a massive disaster in India. The major victims are the young people who after finishing their education were hoping for a great career ahead. It is the TsuNaMo that has crushed their hope. Now that  chowkidar  Modi is going for his re-election, it's time to make him accountable. Image for representational purpose only If the 2014 election was fought on the issue of corruption, 2019 could have been fought on the issue of unemployment. But it doesn't seem to be progressing that way. As the election approaches, Indian weather is becoming hot with topics associated with nationalism such as Kashmir. The separatists and the  deshdrohis  speaking about  azadi  and removal of the army from disturbed areas of Kashmir only help ...